Ideas for our Future
Harnessing our joint Knowledge, Skills and Experience to address the big issues and opportunities of our time
Our topic this month is: Crime, Personal Security and Harm
Underneath the agenda below is a ChatGPT supplied list of crime categories as background to the discussion. The latest Government announcement on policing may be of interest From local to national: a new model for policing - GOV.UK together with Police Performance Framework - GOV.UK. Also the Online Safety Act: explainer - GOV.UK
Agenda
How do we view the current landscape of each of personal security, crime, intimidation, anti-social behaviour and other harm in the UK?
Where do we think the biggest issues lie? What are their root causes? Can the existing system realistically deliver — in terms of capability, capacity and coordination — or is it structurally broken? Who needs to act to solve the issues? Does responsibility sit at national or local level?
What are the key factors around crime attraction, prevention, detection and punishment — and what incentives or disincentives are currently shaping behaviour? What needs improving? How effective can/will Ofcom’s application of the Online safety act be?
How significant are everyday harm, threats and antisocial behaviour – for both adults and children?
Does use of technology to combat all these threats have to be traded against our personal freedoms? Where should the line be drawn? What do we think about Virtual Identity cards and AI face recognition?
How do we tackle inequality of justice including access to justice, legal aid, victim support & compensation?
How will crime and security likely evolve? What about legitimacy i.e. acceptance and consent of people to law and order?
What are the 3 biggest issues? What are the potential solutions that would genuinely shift outcomes, rather than add activity or complexity?
CRIME CATEORIES
OFFLINE CRIME
Crimes involving direct physical threat or coercion.
Primary harm: Physical injury, trauma, fear
System issue: Prevention, early intervention, consistent protection
Low-level offences with high cumulative impact.
Primary harm: Withdrawal from public space, loss of trust
System issue: Under-policed, normalised, weak consequence
Crimes aimed at material gain through physical means.
Primary harm: Financial loss, insecurity, rising crime attraction
System issue: Low detection and deterrence
Structured criminal activity with physical presence.
Primary harm: Violence, exploitation, corruption
System issue: Scale, enforcement capacity, cross-border limits
Crimes affecting collective safety or legitimacy.
Primary harm: Erosion of trust and legitimacy
System issue: Accountability and consistent enforcement
ONLINE CRIME
Crimes exploiting digital financial systems.
Primary harm: Financial loss, trust erosion
System issue: Scale, automation, weak recovery and enforcement
Crimes targeting individuals through digital channels.
Primary harm: Psychological harm, long-term trauma
System issue: Attribution, protection, victim support
Crimes targeting digital infrastructure and systems.
Primary harm: System disruption, economic damage
System issue: Defensive capability, resilience, attribution
Networked, often transnational digital crime.
Primary harm: Mass victimisation, asymmetric power
System issue: Jurisdiction, coordination, institutional mismatch
Crimes that blur online and offline boundaries.
Primary harm: Speed, scale, loss of control
System issue: Anticipation and governance lag
The Discussion Output on this topic is now available at: Crime, Personal Security and Harm